World Cup 2014 – In Praise of: Mark Geiger

Americans are getting more and more into football (“soccer”) and were pretty supportive of the USMNT, who improbably emerged from the Group of Death to make it to the Round of 16.

But what many of them didn’t realize was that the real American hero in this World Cup wasn’t Tim Howard or Julian Green.

He was a 39 year old math teacher from New Jersey.

MLS referee Mark Geiger broke every barrier for US referees in this tournament, his first at this level.

According to the Professional Referee Organization’s (PRO) General Manager, Peter Walton:

“Becoming the first American referee to officiate a knock-out game in the World Cup Finals is testimony to the way Mark Geiger and his two assistants, Joe Fletcher and Sean Hurd, performed throughout the tournament.

 

 

 

Mark’s management skills and application of law, coupled with his dynamic fitness, enabled him to bring to a satisfactory conclusion three games, where the post-match discussion was about the game and not the officiating.

 

 

 

Their performances have indeed raised the positive profile of North American soccer officiating and have raised the bar for others to follow.”

Match Performance

He took two games in the group stages (his second coming even before the illustrious Howard Webb had his first). And while his first match was low profile, his second was anything but.

Zimbio

Geiger in Spain v Chile (Photo: Zimbio)

Spain v. Chile was a tough, aggressive game, and Geiger refereed it like a boss. He was everywhere on the pitch, keeping up with play and communicating firmly but fairly.

I was so impressed with this performance, that I named it amongst my top five in the group and knockout stages.

FIFA must have agreed with me, because they awarded him a knockout stage game: France v. Nigeria.

He was the first American ever to referee a match in the knockout round of the World Cup.

Mark+Geiger+France+v+Nigeria+xy7Bd-NZC9xl

Geiger in France v Nigeria

He had a lot more difficult time in his third match, France v. Nigeria, particularly with a French team that seemed determined to push every possible boundary. He used his preferred style of talking to the players and giving them verbal warnings, but it didn’t work as well here.

He gave a yellow card to Blaise Matuidi for a horror challenge on Ogenyi Onazi. Unfortunately, Onazi was taken away with two broken bones in his leg.

It was the only card he showed in the game.

But it was very difficult for referees in the knockout stages to reach for their cards because of the accumulation rules; just two yellow cards would see a player miss a decisive match all the way up to the semifinals. As I’ve discussed before, this hamstrung the referees and led to some bad situations.

While he did not receive another assignment in the tournament, FIFA did him two honors:

  • He was one of the 14 referees retained until the end of the World Cup, while more experienced referees were sent home. (Though some very good referees were in the latter list only because of the performance of their teams, who moved on, eliminating the referee from consideration.)
  • He was chosen as the fourth official for the first semifinal, refereed by fellow CONCACAF referee Marco Rodriguez of Mexico. He has teamed up with Rodriguez as fourth official before.

Geiger went farther than any American referee has ever gone, and it was clear that FIFA thought very highly of him – quite rightly.

20140624-635392310060754830w

Geiger, lining up with Rodriguez’ team in an earlier match.

So, let’s talk about the fact that he didn’t receive an assignment for the semifinals or the final. Many Americans were upset by this, but it really never was a possibility for a couple of reasons:

Lack of experience: Look at the guys who were chosen and you see years of high-level tournament – including World Cup – experience. Nicola Rizzoli, who got the final, has an impenetrable tournament CV: with a Europa League Final and Champions League Final to his name, not to mention 10 years of Serie A experience.

Geiger just doesn’t have that. He wasn’t even at any of the 2013 “test run” tournaments that FIFA was using to evaluate referees under tournament conditions  this past summer: Confederations Cup, U-20 World Cup, or even the U-17 World Cup (most of the guys at that didn’t make the cut for the World Cup).

Confederation politics and seniority: Refereeing is a lot like ice dancing, in that where you end up has as much (or sometimes more) to do with what you’ve done in the past, and with your seniority within the group, as it does with how you perform.It also has a lot to do with geopolitics.

As a smaller confederation, CONCACAF wasn’t going to get two referees in the last four matches. And the senior ranking CONCACAF referee was Marco Rodriguez, who had World Cup experience behind him. So, when the one match became available, Rodriguez got it and Geiger was given the fourth official slot. Even without the Matuidi incident, it’s still possible Rodriguez would have outranked him, and Rodriguez had a good tournament, too.

So that leads us to 2018.

Rodriguez will retire, and unless some hot shot appears, Geiger will have seniority and World Cup experience on his side. He will be nearing 44, but still under the 45 year limit.

With four more years of experience and FIFA training, and the right support from MLS and PRO, there is no doubt in my mind that Geiger will be a force to be reckoned with in Russia.

Want an American hero in the next World Cup?

Mark Geiger just might be your guy…

Featured photo: Getty

Advertisements

5 comments

  • To adjust some of your comments:

    1. Mark did referee at the 2011 U-20 World Cup, and did so well that he and his crew were selected to referee the final.
    2. Mark was selected by FIFA to referee at the Olympics. taking charge of Spain / Japan and a quarterfinal match: Japan – Egypt.
    3. Mark was the CONCACAF representative to the Club World Cup in 2013 where he refereed the fifth – place match.

    He has the tournament experience.

    Like

    • Sorry…didn’t mean to suggest he didn’t.

      But the WC evaluation process began really in September 2012 and the tournaments I mentioned were part of the evaluation.

      Like

      • My point was not to denigrate his experience, but to explain to non-referee American readers why he could have been passed over for the last three games. No ref got to the World Cup without tournament experience, so that is NOT what I was saying.

        Sorry for the confusion

        Like

        • YoSiUsoLasTarjetas

          That Matuidi tackled doomed the poor guy. But he did get a great seat to watch one of the best in action in the semi’s.

          Like

  • Pingback: MLS Referees – July 28 through August 3 | PLAY THE ADVANTAGE

Tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s